Knowledge

“People believe shit and don’t believe sense,” my supervising doctor said. The comment was in reference to patients who believe remedies without any evidence to support their efficacy will treat disease better than medicines which have robust research behind them proving they work. It wasn’t a comment saying patients shouldn’t believe or do whatever they want, it was a comment that each of us should challenge ourselves to investigate the facts behind claims. It was a nod to science – the scientific method designed to prove that observations are (or are not) significant.

Perhaps the statement wouldn’t have caught my attention in a different era, but with the state of current affairs it did. These days there are attacks on science. There are TV stations and online blogs calling themselves “news outlets” yet report nothing but opinion, and poorly informed opinion at that. There are threats against the true investigative journalist; stories based in research.

Current affairs. The thought that one can simply say whole groups of people don’t exist and think they’ll disappear…or assume they don’t have a right to be who they are. The assertation by certain politicians that experts know less about their industry than folks who never studied it or never worked in it. The propaganda that people who move from one country to another didn’t do so in good faith, didn’t have a dream for a better life, and weren’t needed in the country where they arrived. The dangerous opinion that one’s beliefs are the only beliefs; forgetting that we’ve proven time and time again that all humans are fallible and that diversity of thought and world view make our species stronger.

The ability to think critically and analyze the validity of people’s claims is a form of power. It’s powerful to set one’s emotions aside and examine the truth behind one’s feelings. With a critical approach we can gain knowledge, not just vibes. With knowledge we can grow and change. We can learn to better understand those different from us rather than expect everyone to be like us. We can embrace diversity. We can embrace transitions from one identity to another. We can include everyone. Knowledge helps us understand that prohibiting words like “diversity,” “transition,” and “inclusion” won’t make people who live those realities disappear and is a form of coercion and censorship. 

“People believe shit and don’t believe sense,” my supervising doctor said. I laughed at the comment because in the context it was funny. But it wasn’t funny when I thought about how many people have, do, and will suffer because powerful people are unwilling to believe sense. Unable to hear reason. Disinterested in knowledge. We can’t change other people, but we are responsible for ourselves. I challenge you to look for sense, not shit, when making your decisions in every facet of your life. If each of us challenged ourselves to do that, the world would be different from what it is today.

Positive Transformation

The first time I saw the patient, they weren’t sure if they wanted to take the medications I recommended for lowering their cholesterol and blood pressure. Primary care appointments are conversations. My assessment of their health after reviewing their labs, vital signs, and story suggested that making lifestyle changes (like more exercise and diet adjustments) and starting a few medications would help the patient be healthier and reach their goal of living a long, healthy life. I explained the reasoning behind my recommendations and the patient agreed to think about them. We planned to continue our discussion of possible medications and lifestyle changes at future appointments. As I like to remind my patients, it doesn’t help anyone if I prescribe them medications they won’t take. I’d rather have an honest conversation about the medications I think would help them but only prescribe the medications the patient would like to try.

Primary care is proactive. In other words, the goal of primary care is to prevent the development of disease in the first place or, if a disease is present, to prevent its progression. Contrast primary care with the reactive approach of hospital medicine. The goal of hospital medicine is to treat disease that is unstable or so far along in its course that it can’t be safely managed outside of a hospital. We know we can help people live longer, healthier lives when they have good access to primary care. However, the challenge with primary care is that often the interventions it promotes don’t create visible changes in the present.

For example, people generally don’t feel any different if their cholesterol is high or low. However, we know that high cholesterol over time can lead to clogging of arteries which, in turn, can lead to heart attacks, strokes, and blockages in arteries that feed the legs (causing pain, poor healing, and tissue death). If a patient has high cholesterol and chooses to lower their cholesterol through diet, exercise, and (possibly) medications they are taking important action to prevent heart attack, stroke, and the other complications of clogged arteries. Yet, it can be hard for people to find the motivation to change their lifestyle and (possibly) take medications every day when those changes don’t change how they feel, and the health benefits are intangible (though very real).

I saw the patient who agreed to think about my medication recommendations many months later. They had lost weight and looked more muscular. They’d revamped their lifestyle – they started a balanced exercise program at least 3 days a week and minimized sugars and carbohydrates in their diet in favor of lean meats and vegetables.

“I’m ready to try the cholesterol-lowering medication,” the patient said, bringing up the topic before I did.

It was a complete transformation. “What motivated you to make all these changes?” I asked.

“I decided I want to live a long time still. I have things I want to do,” the patient said.

I found myself smiling long after the patient left. Many people struggle to make all the changes that this patient had to support their health. Yet, this patient had taken their health into their own hands. And, while I’ll never be able to say exactly how their actions changed the course of their life, every bit of research suggests these choices would shape the patient’s future. They’d lowered their probability of dying from heart disease or stroke. They’d lowered their risk of developing heart failure and diabetes. And such a positive transformation, though rare, is the dream of primary care.